Pizza in Downtown
The best pizza in Downtown, New Haven
5 hand-picked pizza spots in Downtown. Part of our wider Pizza guide and Downtown coverage.
Italian & PizzaSiena
Upscale Tuscan-inspired Italian from Chef Tyler Anderson at The Blake Hotel. Seasonal menus and elegant ambiance.
Italian & PizzaOlives and Oil
Modern rustic Italian with elevated pasta, wood-fired dishes, and a lively bar scene in a vintage downtown setting.
Italian &
PizzaVilla Lulu
Villa Lulu is a delightful spot nestled in the heart of New Haven on College Street, right on Restaurant Row at The Shops at Yale. This family-friendly Italian and pizza restaurant offers a modern take on regional Italian cuisine, making it a perfect choice for both casual outings and special family gatherings. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it easy to settle in and enjoy a meal with loved ones. At Villa Lulu, you can expect a thoughtfully curated selection of wines and cocktails that complement the menu, elevating your dining experience. The focus here is not just on the food, but on creating a welcoming environment where friends and families can come together to enjoy hearty portions of classic Italian fare. Whether you're in the mood for a comforting pizza or a delightful pasta dish, you'll find something to satisfy your cravings. This is a place where you can feel at home while enjoying a taste of Italy right in the vibrant neighborhood of New Haven. So, if you’re looking for a place to unwind and savor some good food in a friendly atmosphere, Villa Lulu is definitely worth a visit.
Italian & PizzaBobbis
Detroit-ish style pizza with thick square crusts and crispy edges. A bold new style for New Haven pizza. Opened 2025.
Italian & PizzaBobbi's
Detroit-ish style pizza in New Haven — thick, buttery crust with crispy cheese edges and wild toppings. From the Sherkaan team.