Pizza in Wooster Square
The best pizza in Wooster Square, New Haven
2 hand-picked pizza spots in Wooster Square. Part of our wider Pizza guide and Wooster Square coverage.
Italian & PizzaConsiglio's
A Wooster Street legend since 1938 — old-school Italian dining with Amalfi Coast roots and Sunday supper vibes you can't fake.
Italian & PizzaZeneli Pizzeria
Zeneli Pizzeria is a delightful spot nestled in the heart of Wooster Square, where you can enjoy authentic Neapolitan pizza and a variety of traditional Italian dishes. This family-friendly restaurant offers a warm, welcoming atmosphere that makes it a perfect choice for a casual meal with loved ones or a cozy night out. As you step inside, you’ll be greeted by the enticing aromas of freshly baked pizza and homemade sauces, setting the stage for a truly satisfying dining experience. The menu features classic Italian favorites and expertly crafted pizzas, all made with quality ingredients that reflect the essence of Italian cooking. Whether you’re a pizza aficionado or just looking for a comforting plate of pasta, Zeneli Pizzeria has something to please every palate. Located on Wooster Street, this pizzeria is part of the vibrant local scene that New Haven has to offer. It’s a place where you can savor the flavors of Italy while feeling right at home in a friendly neighborhood setting.