1. Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana
No list of New Haven pizza would be complete without mentioning the legendary Frank Pepe. This iconic spot has been slinging its famous coal-fired pies since 1925, and that crispy, charred crust is pure magic. Try the white clam pizza, which is a classic choice that combines fresh clams, garlic, and a drizzle of olive oil for a taste that’s quintessentially New Haven. Go on a weekday afternoon to avoid the crowd, or make sure to be ready for a line on weekends!
2. Sally’s Apizza
Just a stone's throw away from Frank Pepe, Sally's is another heavyweight in the New Haven pizza ring. Known for its thin crust and classic tomato sauce, each slice is topped with a generous layer of mozzarella that melts to perfection. The Sally’s Special — a mix of pepperoni, mushrooms, and green peppers — is a must-try, and honestly, who can resist that combo? Aim for an early dinner during the week, and enjoy a pie while the sun sets over Wooster Square.
3. Modern Apizza
Modern Apizza isn’t just modern in name but also in flavors! This spot offers a unique twist with its rich sauce and distinctive dough that has a soft yet chewy texture. The “House Special” — featuring pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, and onions — will light up your taste buds and leave you craving more. Stop by for a late-night slice after a gig at Toad’s Place, and you won’t regret it!
4. BAR
Looking for something a bit different? BAR combines the best of both worlds with its pizza and house-brewed beers. Their crust is both unique and delicious, with a slight sweetness that complements the toppings beautifully. The “Margarita” with its fresh basil and tomato sauce is a local favorite. Swing by on a Friday night to soak up the vibe, and don’t forget to grab a pint of their beer brewed right on site!
5. Brick Oven Pizza
Located in the Grand Avenue neighborhood, Brick Oven Pizza is all about that classic, homey feel. Their pizzas are cooked in a traditional brick oven, resulting in a crust that’s crispy yet fluffy. The “Buffalo Chicken Pizza” is a standout, bringing that spicy kick that pairs perfectly with a cold drink. Visit during the Edgewood Park Farmers Market for a fun day out, then grab a slice to fuel your adventures!
6. Pizzeria da Marco
This hidden gem in East Rock is worth the trek for their creative combinations and exceptional crust. Pizzeria da Marco focuses on local ingredients and seasonal specials, making each visit a different experience. Try the “Fig and Prosciutto Pizza” for something a little sweet and savory. Head over on a weekend evening for a laid-back dinner with friends as you enjoy the charming neighborhood vibe!
So there you have it: my top 7 places to grab a slice in New Haven! Whether you're a lifelong local or just passing through, make sure to hit up these spots to truly taste the pizza culture that New Haven is famous for. And hey, if you find yourself craving more local eats or events, don’t forget to follow us on Instagram for all the updates!