1. Arethusa Farm Dairy
When it comes to ice cream in New Haven, Arethusa Farm Dairy is an icon! Known for their farm-to-table approach, their flavors are rich and creamy, made from milk straight from their Connecticut cows. You can’t go wrong with the Salted Caramel or the Blackberry — both are heavenly! Head over to their 1000 Chapel St. location on a sunny afternoon and grab a scoop or two to savor while you stroll around downtown.
2. Ben & Jerry's
If you’re craving something fun and funky, Ben & Jerry's on 25 Broadway has got your back! With flavors like Chunky Monkey and Cherry Garcia, you know you're in for a treat. Plus, their innovative seasonal flavors keep things exciting. Swing by for a scoop or pour it into a sundae form — it’s always a party inside! Perfect for after dinner when you’re catching up with friends.
3. Sweet Claude's
For a truly unique experience, Sweet Claude's in Westville is where it's at! They offer artisanal ice creams that are made from scratch, including vegan and dairy-free options. Try their standout flavor, Peanut Butter Cup, and pair it with one of their homemade waffle cones. Pop in on weekends to avoid the long lines and enjoy a treat while exploring the charming neighborhood.
4. Fritz's Nut Butter and Ice Cream
If you love crunchy and nutty, you have to check out Fritz's Nut Butter and Ice Cream on 263 Crown St. Their unique offerings include delicious ice creams and nut butters that’s perfect for your summer scoop. Don’t miss the Maple Pecan ice cream topped with fresh roasted pecans. Visit during their afternoon hours to catch some awesome local vibes!
5. Shake Shack
While they’re primarily known for their burgers, Shake Shack also serves up some of the best frozen custard around! Located at 5 College St, their Shack Attack Concrete is a must-try, featuring rich chocolate custard packed with fudge, brownie, and chocolate sprinkles. After grabbing a burger, finish your meal with a frozen treat that’ll hit the spot! Perfect for a family night out.
6. Randy's Wooster St. Deli
For a twist on traditional ice cream, Randy's Wooster St. Deli brings the sweet side of New Haven together with their delicious frozen yogurt! With a variety of flavor options, you can build your own parfait with fresh toppings. Go for the Peanut Butter Cup yogurt topped with crushed Oreos for a real win! This is a perfect stop after exploring the nearby parks.
7. Milkcraft
If you haven’t tried Milkcraft yet, you’re seriously missing out! Located at 1124 Chapel St, they serve up delicious rolled ice cream, made fresh right in front of you. The Nutella Crunch is a fan favorite, and watching your treat come to life is part of the fun. Head there late in the afternoon for a cool treat that’ll leave you buzzing with excitement!